Using Name Celebrity to
Promote Special Events
Focus, 08/26/1987
Eagle
Associates Soar With Confidence
Focus, 08/19/1987, 2120 words.
How Effective is Your
Direct Mail?
Focus, 06/17/1987
Choosing an
Artist/Designer
Focus, 06/17/1987
How to Select a Modeling
Agency
Focus, 06/17/1987
Jazzing Up the Billboard
Industry
Focus,
06/17/1987
City
Puts New Emphasis on Sports to Lure Tourists
Focus, 04/01/1987, 2280 words.
Always the Bridesmaid:
What’s Wrong in Philadelphia’s Wooing of Corporate Relocations
Focus, 03/25/1987
We
the People' Gears Up for the Bicentennial Bash: Part Celebratory, Part Cerebral
Focus, 02/04/1987, 3768 words
How Meeting Planners Rate
Philadelphia
Focus, 09/10/1986
Conference Centers Breed
Confusion
Focus, 09/10/1986
Marketing: In Search of
an Audience
Focus, 09/10/1986
The Challenge of Meeting
Publicity
Focus, 09/10/1986
Convention Bureau: Selling
the City
Focus, 09/10/1986
Cities
Battle for Conventions' Big Bucks
Focus, 09/10/1986, 2911 words.
The
Mummers Gain 'Professional' Status With New Contract That Could Bring in Millions
Focus, 05/07/1986, 1518 words.
Eagle Associates Soar With Confidence
By Thomas Derr
08/19/1987
Focus
Pg. 96
Philadelphia, PA, US -- WHEN America's founding
fathers gathered in Philadelphia to sign the Declaration of Independence a little
over 200 years ago, it was hometown celebrity Benjamin
Franklin who wryly remarked to the gathering of
rebels: "Now we must all hang together or shortly we shall hang
separately."
Earlier this year, employees of Eagle Associates,
the in-house advertising agency of John Wanamaker, the landmark Philadelphia
department store chain, were faced with a similar proposition. Following its
purchase of the 16-store Wanamaker's operation, new owner Woodward &
Lothrop (itself a 15-store chain based in the Washington, D.C. area) announced
it would consolidate its operations in Washington.
That decision meant the end of what was one of
the region's largest in-house advertising operations, with annual billings of
approximately $25 million.
NO FOREWARNING: Apparently executives at Carter
Hawlye Hale (the group that sold Wanamaker's to Woodward & Lothrop) had no
forewarning that such a move was being planned. But according to some of the
employees at Eagle Associates, it was something that might have been foreseen.
"We had a feeling there would be changes
among the employees simply because of the proximity of the marketplace,"
explains Liz Sweet, director of media services for the now-defunct department.
"It was almost as if those markets actually touched. We have 16 stores,
they have 15 stores in Maryland and Delaware. And here they were coming up to
crack the Philadelphia market as Wanamaker's. So we knew there was a
possibility of cutbacks."
Sweet says she and her associates would have
preferred the new owners to have kept the entire department intact in order to
maintain a continuity in the Wanamaker's identity. But the size of the combined
operations made such a plan economically unfeasible.
Faced with impending layoffs, the approximately
25 employees at Eagle Associates had a number of choices. A few were invited to
relocate to Washington, D.C., and join the newly consolidated advertising
operation at Woodward & Lothrop. Those that remained, 19 in all, were left
out to hang.
The problem facing the group was relatively
straightforward -- how to get back into the job market. But while a number of
the Eagle Associates employees could boast of many years of experience on both
the agency and the retail side, some of the other employees -- except for some
freelance projects -- had worked only at Wanamaker's
"We spent so much time promoting other
peoples' products and services that when it came to promoting ourselves --
that's the last thing you think of," says Sweet.
Further complicating the challenge was the fact
that the Eagle Associates personnel were very busy phasing out the
Philadelphia- based operations while trying to look for new jobs.
MARKETING GUIDANCE: Sweet says she talked to
several people in the agency world -- in particular Tom Ong of McAdams and Ong
-- asking for guidance as to where the employees' portfolios and creative
samples might be best marketed.
"So one day I was thinking -- we work on
sales promotion all the time, so maybe we should promote ourselves. So we got
together, called a meeting, and said: `Look, what have we got to lose? We've
already lost our jobs.' And everybody thought it was a great idea," Sweet
recalls.
From that point it became an intense joint
effort to develop a complete campaign aimed at promoting the
soon-to-be-unemployed advertising professionals to new would-be employers. Now
a cynic may say that such a plan is a perfect example of the adage:
"Misery loves company." But according to the former Eagles, a more
appropriate adage is "There's strength in numbers."
The result was a direct mail package centered
around a multi- fold brochure announcing "A Ton & A Half of
Talent," and giving the names, positions, and home telephone numbers of
the 19 new job seekers. The name was derived as a result of a joke by a
professional associate of one of the Eagle employees -- that the agency
"had a lot of heavyweights" working there.
According to Fred Payne, former art director of
Eagle Associates, that heavyweight marker is no exaggeration. Payne himself has
33 years of experience. All told, the 19 professionals represent more than 280
combined years of experience in both retail and agency situations.
Sweet, for example, was an employee at Wanamaker
for only the past two years. Prior to that, she had 25 years of advertising
agency experience.
"As a result, I was very familiar with
moving around among several agencies. So when it came to John Wanamaker, I knew
that a lot of people really had worked their whole career there."
ANOTHER MONKEY WRENCH: According to Louise
Reeves, senior designer at Eagle Associates, the fact that several of the
individuals had worked exclusively on the retail side could have been an
additional monkey wrench for those job seekers.
"You have to remember, that among a lot of
people, especially those who have been in the retail industry -- there's an
unfounded fear that they might not be able to do anything but retail artwork or
retail writing," says Reeves. "But I've known a number of people over
the years, especially designers, who did nothing but retail. But just let them
in the door over there at Spiro, and they
went crazy over them."
Stereotyping advertising professionals with
retail experience isn't fair, because they get labeled, Reeves says. And that's
something the industry has to realize, she adds.
"The fact is, if you're a good art
director, you can do anything. Naturally, you have an expertise. But these
people here have had extensive training."
In other words, just because an individual
hasn't done something doesn't mean he
or she can't do it at all.
INTERESTING CHALLENGE: Getting that point across
to potential employers posed an
interesting challenge. According to Sweet, the
initial mailing was limited to about 200 targeted recipients.
"You have to remember that the job market
for retail is drying up -- it's not a matter of just going to another place,
because those jobs were being eliminated anyway," explains Sweet. "So
we were looking at companies that still seemed to maintain an in-house
capability."
These included major manufacturers with in-house
advertising capabilities, such as Hershey's and Campbell Soup -- also
publishing firms, with direct response capabilities and direct mail printers.
In addition, the package was sent to creative
directors of advertising agencies, radio and TV stations, and a number of
newspapers and business publications.
"At the retail level, several people here
already knew individuals that would be major factors in our effort," Sweet
says. "We figured that if they couldn't use someone in their particular
department, they would at least put us through to the different areas. And it
seems we were very lucky -- we only had one sent back, and that was because the
mailing address was wrong."
COVER LETTER: The group also created a cover
letter to send along in response to requests for resumes that came in either to
the John Wanamaker's office, which was available to them until June 30, or to
their individual homes.
"When someone sent in the card requesting
several resumes, we had a very nice letter that went in front of the
resumes," Sweet notes. "Now it was each individual's personal
responsibility to send in their resumes, but we had copies made of each
request. So it was very well organized."
In addition, Sweet says the group was pleasantly
surprised at the response it received from its initial mailing, if only because
of the fact that the summer is a notoriously slow time.
According to Sweet, the direct mail piece was
planned to have a maximum shelf life of two weeks. But thanks to a timely
pick-up in the Philadelphia Inquirer, its effectiveness was extended a bit
longer. This kind of increased media awareness is important in spreading the
group's message, adds former merchandise coordinator Ernest Reed.
"The fact that you have a group of people
that worked so well together and can produce something is a very major factor
is job marketing skills," he says.
"This is a very small staff that generated
a tremendous amount of work," agrees Reeves. "In an agency you have
two to three times the number of people doing that work. It's really
incredible. The only way it works is that everyone worked so close together.
That was a special quality that helped enhance everyone's individual efforts."
TIGHT MARKET: The importance of that message
becomes especially clear when one considers just how tight the job market is.
"We are not the only ones that are
experiencing this," explains Sweet. "Several months ago 20 people at
Hawthorne -- the in-house agency for Colonial Penn -- were also let go. The
fact is, you have too many people out in the marketplace at once."
Thus, it places greater pressures on the
individual's effort at pursuing a job.
"But this way a person will send his resume
out and we act almost as agents for each other. We can do networking much
better this way than on an individual basis," Sweet explains. "And it
worked."
Another consideration is the fact that when the
individuals scheduled interviews, they brought along resumes of other people in
whom the interviewers might be interested.
Now togetherness may be fine up to a point, but
naturally there have to be limits. According to Sweet, determining where the
collective effort ends and individual effort begins is largely a matter of
selling yourself.
"If they are interested in you when you go
up for the interview, that's your individual responsibility, and your rapport
with the person, and your individual talent," she explains.
While all have interviewed with one firm or
another, so far three of the 19 people involved in the Eagle Associates' direct
mail package have found jobs. Several others have picked up extensive freelance
work as a result. And, Sweet notes, it is entirely possible that several of the
former Eagle employees may decide that full-time freelance is their best avenue
for success.
NOT ENTIRELY HEARTENING: As copywriter Bill
Sternman suggests, the process has not been entirely heartening.
"It's a very tough market out there. Very,
very tough," he says. "And that's a problem. I can write. I want to
be a writer and the market is tight not only for copywriters, but for writers
in general."
Still, the remaining job seekers don't appear to
have reached the point of desperation.
"We're all trying to take a little time
off," says Reeves. "We haven't had any time off because we knew it
was coming -- so we held off on our vacations. I'm doing freelance, so I want
some time off from behind the board."
"I've been putting off some employers,"
adds Reeves. "I don't want to start at Franklin Mint or these places just
yet, because I just feel we need a little time to shift gears."
An educated guess as to when most of the job
seekers would make themselves available would be September, Sweet says, which
is the traditional time for pick-up business in the advertising industry. And
hopefully, the former Eagle Associates will be rested up enough to return to
the rigor of the agency lifestyle.
IN-HOUSE vs. 'REAL': Some people may not be
aware of the similarities between in-house agencies and real agencies, Payne
notes.
"You have to remember you have same
positions, copywriters, art directors, and so on. Only the company structure is
different in the retail shop versus the agency."
Another important difference is that results in
the in-house shop generally are more immediate, Sweet adds.
According to Reeves, there was also a greater
level of excitement in the in-house Wanamaker agency.
"It wasn't like these other places where
you can walk into a cold building in the suburbs," she says. "You
were thrust into excitement. You had the organ playing, the people coming
through, and it was just alive. There was something different and exciting
here. There was something about retailing, about that department store, that
turns us on."
WILL EXCITEMENT CARRY OVER? But will that level
of excitement and enthusiasm be transferable to the outside agency? Reed, for
one, thinks so.
"The type of attitude we have learned to
work with is an asset for anybody on the outside wanting to take on more
people," Reed declares. "The asset is that they work well with
anyone. It's not cutthroat competitiveness without real talent, which you
sometimes come up against. There are no jealousies among the people in this department."
Whether or not that attitude will stand the test
of time in the turbulent "outside" advertising world is anyone's
guess. In the meantime, the remaining former Eagle associates may need all the
rest they can get.
City Puts New Emphasis on Sports to Lure
Tourists
By Thomas Derr
04/01/1987
Focus
Pg. 26
Philadelphia, PA, US -- It will come as no
surprise to avid viewers of the recent America's Cup races hullabaloo that
hitherto "unknown" sporting events, if properly marketed, can generate
enormous profits.
That fact is also evident to the Philadelphia
Convention and Visitors Bureau. As a matter of fact, that organization recently
instituted a program aimed specifically at the sports marketplace.
Named to head up the effort is James P. Tuppeny,
associate athletic director at the University of Pennsylvania and director of
the Penn Relays for the past 19 years. In his new position, Tuppeny will hold
the title of executive director of athletics for the Philadelphia Convention
and Visitors Bureau.
"The basic idea is that for many years,
Philadelphia has not been getting its share of the large athletics market that
exists in the United States," explains Tuppeny.
He notes that this is in spite of the fact that
Philadelphia has four wonderful professional teams, several collegiate teams
and several amateur teams. Faced with this situation, Tuppeny's new job is to
spearhead an effort to bring more competitions into the city, as well as more
clinics, meetings, tournaments, seminars, and health and recreation related
activities.
CLEARINGHOUSE: "What I am trying to do is
bring all the key people together -- to be a leader in this, and act as a
clearinghouse of information to corporations and other entities who may be
interested in getting involved from a sponsorship standpoint," Tuppeny
explains. "In addition, it will be my responsibility to direct people who
are interested in attracting such business and sporting events as to how to
make a presentation before a committee or get on the so-called round-robin
list."
The round-robin list for a tournament typically
involves a pre-established rotation in location of a tournament site from year
to year, he explains. Tuppeny has had experience in such events on both
national and international levels, and particularly in the track and field
category.
According to Thomas O. Muldoon, president of the
Philadelphia Convention and Visitors Bureau, such a sports-oriented committee
did exist for several years on a less institutionalized basis, but its success
depended largely on the personal strength and abilities of the committee
chairman.
"Jack Kelly was the chairman of it for a
long time," Muldoon says. "Kelly had a unique ability and more time
to devote to the program, plus his work and his interests kind of flowed
together more than they would for most people."
One of the most impressive feats the committee
accomplished under Kelly was the attraction of the NCAA basketball tournament
to Philadelphia during the bicentennial year of 1976. Thanks to the dedication
and hard work of Kelly and other players such as former Temple University
athletic director Ernie Casales, the 1976 venture was so successful that a
return engagement became a reality in 1981. But during the years since Kelly's
death, that committee has been largely inactive, Muldoon notes. Thus the reason
for the development of the new program.
THREE-IN-ONE: "It really came about as a
result of a meeting that included David Brenner, who at that time was the
city's Director of Commerce; and Bill Giles, who is our chairman; and Fred
Shabel, the chairman of Spectacor," says Muldoon.
"It was their recommendation that we think
in terms of making it more institutionalized and that perhaps a better place to
put it would be in the Convention and Visitors Bureau."
To head up that sports division, the executive
committee identified three different types of individuals. One type of
candidate was someone who had tremendous contacts throughout various
professional and amateur organizations in the sports world. The second type of
candidate would be a "name" athlete, such as a Tug McGraw or a Garry
Maddox -- people who are closely identified with the city of Philadelphia and
could readily use their contacts and personalities to help promote the city. The
third avenue involved hiring an individual who worked with a major local
professional sports team who not only had an interest and knowledge in sports,
but also had strong public relations and promotional skills.
"In the end, what we decided would be the
most effective would be to get a veteran in amateur sports -- and with all his
experience with the Penn Relays, we decided that Jim Tuppeny made the most
sense," says Muldoon. About half of Tuppeny's time will be spent on trying
to bring amateur conventions and athletic events into the city. And according
to Muldoon, Tuppeny is particularly qualified to pursue such goals.
"We think that's very do-able, because in
almost all cases there are not professional convention managers involved, it's
usually the local guy who handles all of that," Muldoon says. "It's
the guy at Penn, or the guy in Kansas City, wherever the case may be. And Jim
knows a ton of those people, and knows about networking those kinds of people."
ALSO PROMOTE AMATEUR SPORTS: Another 25 percent
of Tuppeny's time will be spent trying to promote some of the existing amateur
sporting events that happen in the city that are not as well known to the
general public either in Philadelphia or on a national basis.
"The Philadelphia Half Marathon, for
example, is considered to be a real first-class event among people who follow
track and running," Muldoon notes. "The people who work with the
Philadelphia Marathon also work very, hard and could use some additional
financial support or perhaps a slightly different marketing concept."
One of Philadelphia's most prominent annual
amateur sporting events could serve as the focus for a full weekend of
activities, Muldoon notes. He projects an Army-Navy Weekend that might include
a college football double-header, possibly with Penn against Villanova at the
Vet on a Friday night, and then the Army-Navy classic on a Saturday afternoon.
Such a series, and all the accompanying
pageantry, could prove particularly attractive
for television -- at least for an ESPN program, Muldoon says.
WOMEN'S EVENTS: According to Tuppeny, there are
a number of other specific sporting events currently under consideration that
will probably be highlighted by the new division of the Convention and Visitors
Bureau. On February 25, for example, the Big East Women’s' Basketball
Tournament comes here to Philadelphia for the first of a five year tour. In
addition, Tuppeny is working on a women’s' pro tennis tournament that would
have a tentative date for October, 1987.
"We're trying to get the Final Four
basketball program for Women in 1990," says Tuppeny. "We're also
trying to get several Athletic Congress track meets, the IC4As, and the NCAA
field hockey championships for women in 1988 or 1989. Also in 1989, we're
making an effort to get the NCAA track and field championships."
Another key amateur sport possibility is
lacrosse, where the hotbed is really between Baltimore and upstate New York,
Muldoon notes: "Well, where's a more logical place than Philadelphia to
have the national championship every year?"
SHORT-TERM EVENTS: Other possibilities in 1990
include the sports information directors' convention and the Athletics Congress
convention, Tuppeny adds. But there are more short-term events planned, as
well. Over the Fourth of July weekend, for example, the National Age Group
track and field championships will be held in Philadelphia, and major league
baseball's summer meetings are scheduled for June and July.
"The feeling was that professional sports,
in terms of bringing in events, was a little tough to do," explains
Muldoon. "For example, the Super Bowl is going to go to either a warm
weather city or one that has a dome. And basketball, which we've had several
times, we will probably not get again unless we build a 25,000 or 30,000 seat
arena."
On the other hand, championship college events
such as women sports, which Muldoon says are emerging sports, as well as the
wide variety conventions and other meetings that are connected with amateur
sports is enormous.
Although an NFL owners' meeting can bring in a
certain amount of prestige for a city, it also will account only 50 or 100
people at most. A similar meeting of athletic trainers or medical trainers from
a college organization will generally bring in at least 350 attendees.
Such a plan also fits in well with the city's
current hotel product, too, Muldoon notes.
"You don't necessarily need a big
convention center for that kind of stuff. It requires 200 rooms, 300 rooms, or
maybe 350," he says. "Although once in a while you'll get something
bigger than that."
TOUCHING ALL AGES: In addition, there is the
fact that an interest in sports tends to transcend all age groups, economic
levels, and professional interests.
"It could involve the guy who never played
sports in high school and then becomes at age 40 an avid golfer, tennis player
or racquetball player," Muldoon says. "Somewhere along the line it's
going to touch everybody."
And that kind of interest could be developed
into important community-based support for promoting Philadelphia's home-based
sporting activities to the rest of the country.
"There have been a number of people who
have called here already or who have called Jim saying 'Gee, I'd like to be part
of it,'" explains Muldoon.
If the effort were aimed at trying to sell
tickets to a banquet, or trying to raise money for some great charity, Muldoon
says he "rests assured" that nobody would ever call. But the quality
and the variety of people who have expressed sincere interest in being a part
of this new effort is very real.
"I guess whether we are male or female, we
all seem to have a little bit of a boy or girl in us, and my guess is that most
people won't mind donating an hour and a half a month to be part of it if the
right event could happen," Muldoon says. "So I think it's going to
work, and I think Jim, with the combination of his contacts and his enthusiasm
is the right guy to do it."
PRIME TARGETS: One of the other prime targets
for the new sports orientation of the Convention and Visitors Bureau is
national corporations.
"A lot of the national corporations,
especially product companies, already are doing a tremendous amount of
sponsoring," says Muldoon. "Look at every major marathon, every major
sporting event -- and especially this year with the college bowls -- you always
see a Sunkist, or a Xerox, a Kraft, or a Campbell's Soup, and in most cases,
the companies who do that sponsoring do not do anything
in Philadelphia."
The fact that few, if any, national corporations
sponsor key sporting events in Philadelphia is mainly a case of someone not
making the effort to make would-be sponsors aware of the advantages that might
be realized from participating in Philadelphia-based activities, Muldoon says.
Philadelphia is both the fifth largest city, and
the fourth largest television market in the United States. That fact must be
emphasized more if the city is to overcome the national advertisers' tendency
to skip from one regional center to another -- from New York to Washington to
Atlanta to New Orleans, he explains.
Apparently that message is just beginning to get
out.
"We've had two companies in two weeks,
major corporations, who have called us, and said they're thinking about
spending some money in 1988 on a sporting event, and they asked if we had any
ideas?" Muldoon notes. "Talk is cheap, but I'm not sure if before we
started this sports division, that there was anyone they could have contacted
to simply explore the possibility. We look at that as a real benefit."
That combination of factors -- the population
and the television market that exists in Philadelphia -- will be instrumental
selling tools if the city is to bring in additional convention business and
sponsorship dollars from sources related to athletics. And that can be done by
building on existing events.
"I think we can take some of the things
that are already going on in the city and make them a little bigger, a little
more special, and then get some people up there in New York and LA and Chicago
to say 'Hey, why haven't we done more in Philadelphia?'" explains Muldoon.
THREE-YEAR COMMITMENT: But just how much bigger
and more special is still unclear. So far the bureau has not developed any specific
projections as to the amount of additional income that can be derived from new
sports-related business.
"We have a marketing plan that is on a
fiscal year starting July 1," Muldoon says. "And part of what we'll
be doing is coming up with some numbers and goals for hotel rooms, and what
we're looking for in sponsorship dollars."
According to Muldoon, it is usually the same
group of companies that is involved in the sponsorship of most of the major
events nationwide.
"It's also the same advertising agencies --
the J. Walter Thompson's in New York, Ted Bates -- they are all sitting there
and spending or giving directions to the Krafts and the Eastman Kodaks and the
rest of them, saying: 'Gee, you ought to be in this market with this kind of
thing,'" he explains. "But what we're beginning to see now is that
people are calling us and asking us what we have to offer. So we're still
learning that part of the business a little bit."
"But I think a year from now we'll probably
have a good chance to bring an awful lot of money to the city," Muldoon
adds. "Right now we have a three year commitment to this program and we
will certainly evaluate it as we go along. But I think within a year you'll be
seeing some real results."
'We the People' Gears Up for the
Bicentennial Bash:
Part Celebratory, Part Cerebral
By Thomas Derr
02/04/1987
Focus
Pg. 16
Philadelphia, PA, US -- As plans currently
stand, the bicentennial celebration for the U.S. constitution which will be
held throughout 1987 in Philadelphia offers a rather paradoxical good news/bad
news scenario.
The bad news is that it may not reach the level
of glamour and commercial appeal of last year's Statue of Liberty extravaganza.
The good news is that it probably won't have the same kind of glitz and
commercialism to which the grand lady of Liberty Island was subjected.
TWO-FOLD PROBLEM: "One thing we won't be
seeing in this program is 200 Elvis Presley look-alikes," says Dianne L.
Semingson, president and chief executive officer of We the People 200, the
organization which is coordinating the year-long celebration program.
According to Semingson, the basic problem
confronting the planners of this year's bicentennial celebration is two-fold.
On the one hand, the memory of last year's Statute of Liberty extravaganza
places certain expectations in the minds of the media and the public at large
-- especially when there is serious talk of creating a television program that
will rival last year's party in New York.
"It makes it more difficult to come up with
a celebration, a television program, that captures the imagination of the
American public, because the constitution really is just four pieces of
paper," Semingson explains. "With the Statue of Liberty you had this
beautiful woman -- the symbol of liberty is much easier, more tangible, and
more visual. Our challenge is much more difficult -- to try to visualize and
concretize four pages for the American public."
STRIKING A BALANCE: Therefore, the challenge to We
the People 200 is to have a celebration that merits putting on a national
event. And that, notes Semingson, necessitates striking a balance between the
"celebratory and the cerebral."
"I think the most important legacy that we
can leave after 1987 in Philadelphia is a much more educated and a much more
aware populace," Semingson says. "But my fear is if we cannot figure
out what the hook is to capture the American people's attention -- to capture
the imagination of the American people -- then we will not succeed in making
them more aware and more educated. That's why I think the real challenge is in
trying to balance between education and celebration."
According to Semingson, the greatest
concentration of activities originally took place between the time the 55
original delegates arrived in Philadelphia on May 25, 1787, and the time they
emerged from behind closed doors with a new constitution on September 17. In
that sense, the greatest concentration of effort of the bicentennial
celebration will mirror the same time that the constitutional convention was
held here 200 years ago. Currently, there are more than 200 different events
relating to the bicentennial celebration of the constitution that are scheduled
to take place in and around Philadelphia throughout 1987.
STARTED EARLY: Much of the credit for the
development of this year's activities belongs to Hobart G. Cawood, chairman of
We the People 200 and director of Independence National Historical Park.
Cawood, along with his associates in the park service, began laying plans for
some kind of recognition of the constitution's 200th anniversary in 1981.
That initial planning followed closely on the
heels of another 200th anniversary celebration -- the bicentennial of the
Declaration of Independence, which was held in 1976 and for many people simply
lived up to all the expectations and pre-event hype to which Philadelphians
were subjected. But according to Cawood, the experience of the 1976
bicentennial can be viewed as a positive force for this year's celebration.
"I think we may very well get as many
visitors this year, or maybe even more than we did in 1976," Cawood says.
"Granted, we don't have as many big conventions, and people haven't been
thinking about the bicentennial of the constitution for long enough to let it
sink in or to reach great expectations. But I suspect after it is over,
everyone will say that this was better than the bicentennial of the Declaration
of Independence -- if only because we were sort of an hour late, and a dollar short,
and we worked under pressure, and there hasn't been a great deal of publicity,
and there hasn't been a great deal of expectations built up."
PHILADELPHIA, A FOCAL POINT: Cawood predicts
that it will be an inexpensive celebration compared to 1976, but he also notes
that many of the cultural institutions and educational institutions in
Philadelphia will be playing a much more thorough role than they did in 1976.
"Also, I think as a result of this
celebration unlike 1976, Philadelphia is going to be the focal point in
1987," Cawood adds. "In 1976, although we were the site where the
Declaration of Independence was passed, there was an attempt to do bicentennial
things in several communities throughout the country. This year there's no other
community that is doing anything on the magnitude or in the manner of the kinds
of things we will be doing. This year we're going to be
the big hog at the trough."
Cawood notes that the historical park will play
host to three major exhibits during 1987. One exhibit, "Miracle at
Philadelphia," is already underway at the Second Bank of the United
States. It tells the story of the constitutional convention through many of the
documents that were associated with it, as well as through an audio-visual
program.
On May 1, at Old City Hall at 5th and Chestnut
Sts., one of the original English Magna Chartas, this one dating from 1296,
will go on display. May 1, is also Law Day in the United States. And according
to Cawood, the Magna Charta is a kind of ancestor of the American constitution
and provided much of the foundation for what our forefathers put into it. A
seven minute film explaining the correlation between the Magna Charta and the
constitution will accompany the document itself.
COMPUTERIZED EXHIBIT: On May 13, an exhibit
called "A Promise of Permanency" (after the remark made by Benjamin
Franklin about the constitution -- that it seems to offer a promise of
permanency) will open at the Visitors Center.
According to Cawood, "A Promise of
Permanency" will include a computerized, interactive exhibit paid for by
Bell of Pennsylvania. The program will provide visitors with an opportunity to
test their knowledge on the constitution, or to explore or do some personal
research on the constitution or constitutional issues through the exhibits and
through one of 16 personal computers that will
have many outlets tied into the computers.
"It provides the ability to pick out the
issue you want to learn more about, and bring it out on film or
videotape," explains Cawood. "I think it is really going to be
state-of-the-art, because the people who are designing the system for us also
have done computer exhibits for IBM and for Disney World."
GOVERNOR'S BALL: In addition, We the People 200 will
erect a pavilion on Independence Mall to serve as the site for a huge
assortment of activities, festivals, programs, and daily concerts by musical
groups from all 50 states. For example, it will be the site of an international
festival -- the "Festival of Nations," as well as the Governors'
Ball, on the evening of May 24 -- a costumed party for the governors of the
original 13 states and their guests, and the pavilion will serve as the meeting
place for a joint session of the U.S. Congress on July 16.
During the day of May 24th, the 13 governors
will host a Governors' Conference, which will explore the current state of the
states -- with particular emphasis on issues such as how the system of
federalism has worked, the relationship between the federal government and each
governor's own state government, and what has happened to the system through
the years.
"Each governor will bring with him the head
of his bicentennial commission, a scholar, probably from a university in his
state; a high school student, and they will be part of the delegation from each
state," Cawood explains. "The next day is the actual 200th
anniversary of the opening of the constitutional convention, and the governors
will participate in those opening exercises on May
25."
During that same weekend, there will be a 1787
Philadelphia festival which will seek to recreate for modern-day Americans what
the second largest English-speaking city in the country was like in 1787, notes
Semingson.
"The late 1700s was a time of great enlightenment
in this country," she explains. "That's why we think it would be
especially interesting to see people in costumes, and have great oratorical
debates out on Independence Mall. That would have been very common in 1787. So
I think that activity will be a fun and educational festival to reenact what
life was like 200 years ago. It will be very accessible to the public -- and
very festive, and in the interest of the educational emphasis we are
seeking."
HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE: According to one area educator
and public official, activities such as the one described above, which is
geared primarily at highlighting First Amendment freedoms, "really get at
the heart of what we should be thinking about, at least from the historian's
perspective -- our government and the constitution and its contribution to
American development, American civilization."
Lawrence Curry is a professor of history at the
Philadelphia College of Art, editor of the Valley Forge Journal, a publication
of the Valley Forge Historical Society, and a former Montgomery County
commissioner. That background gives him an unusual perspective into just how
important a celebration such as the bicentennial of the constitution can be in
explaining the importance which this 200 year-old document still has to the
average citizen in 1978.
TOWN MEETINGS: One major attempt to bring home
the importance of the U.S. constitution to the average citizen involves a
series of 12 town meetings that will be held periodically throughout the year
in different neighborhoods of Philadelphia. According to Semingson, each of the
town meetings will pick a different subject which has constitutional bearing.
There will be an issue of Abortion and the
Constitution which will be held in the Northeast. And discussion on the issue
of a clean environment will occur in the Bridesburg area, which has several
industrial and chemical plants.
"Each of the 12 will be held in a different
neighborhood and will have a different topic," Semingson says. "And
each topic has been selected for that particular neighborhood. The question is:
'If the environment is the biggest issue in our neighborhood, what does the
constitution say about that? Is there a relationship?' And I think it is going
to be an exciting way to bring the
constitution alive and make it relevant to the
individual guy on the street, and the individual guy who is living in a
rowhouse."
According to Curry, the town meeting activities
bring home to the community the importance at least of municipal government or
a borough government, and of government in general.
Curry notes that the challenge of explaining the
importance of this idea is particularly important today, 200 years after the
constitution was written, when the cry of "get government off our
backs" has gained increasing play among certain political leaders.
In fact, the involvement of government in
certain aspects of society represents some democratic sense of the majority at
work -- desiring protection of the environment, regulations in industry, and so
forth, he says.
AS A LIVING DOCUMENT: "I think the
constitution for most people has a symbolic role, and not a real or immediate
role," Curry explains. "In that sense, the celebration is in part
celebrating some of the symbolism of the constitution. That's why I think it is
important to look for some kind of program to show both how that constitution
structured the government and the significance of the
government that was structured by it -- not only
in the 18th century, but as it evolved."
For that reason, Curry points to activities such
as the interactive computer exhibit -- "The Promise of Permanency" --
as possible ways of clearly explaining the role which the constitution has in
affecting critical modern issues, and subsequently, the lives of individual
citizens.
"Such a program helps to emphasize that
idea of permanent government and how some of those issues can be resolved, but
at the same time keeping the document flexible so it would be responsive to
critical issues in subsequent periods of our history," Curry says.
"That's what is so unique about this document. And I think that uniqueness
-- its flexibility, is something that should be stressed."
"Times change," Curry adds. "And
the brilliance of the constitution is that it changes with the times -- and the
citizenry can use that authority to respond to their current problems."
TV PROGRAMS: Other plans in the works call for
major television programming that will be produced by Smith-Hemion Productions,
who Semingson describes as being "the most preeminent television
programming producers in the country today."
Included in their credits are Baryshnikov on
Broadway, and specials for Ann-Margaret, Barbra Streisand and Frank Sinatra, to
name but a few.
"We don't know yet which network will be
involved -- it's up to the producers as part of their contractual arrangement
with us to go to the networks and sell them a program," Semingson
explains. "But we are hoping that there will be several hours of
programming in which we will include the televising of the Grand Federal
Procession, which of course will be a parade to end all parades."
It was on July 1, 1788, that Philadelphians
first learned that enough states had ratified the constitution for it to become
the law of the land. Within four days, by July 4, the population of
Philadelphia had swelled from 35,000 to 45,000 and the city played host to the
largest parade ever held in the New World.
PARADE OF INDUSTRIES: "According to a 1788
account by Pennsylvania Judge Francis Hopkinson, the procession was made up
primarily of all the industries that existed in the country at that time -- the
trades particularly: butchers, bakers, candlestick makers, hide tanners,
blacksmiths, and such," Semingson says.
As described in part of Judge Hopkinson's
account, one of the floats of the parade was a Greek pavilion with 13 columns,
ten of which stood upright -- representing the states that had ratified the
constitution, and three columns lying down to represent the three that had not
yet. Another float consisted of a large ship that was built on a flatbed which
in turn was pulled by horses.
According to the account, this was the first
time that the terminology "ship of state" had ever been used,
Semingson says.
"I guess the one I like the most, from an
emotional-sociological standpoint -- was a float built by the bakers,"
Semingson explains. "They constructed a big working oven on a flatbed, and
as they went down the parade route, they gave out small loaves of bread to the
people along the way. And the sign on the flat was 'In order that Americans
should not go hungry.'"
According to Semingson, current plans are to use
Judge Hopkinson's account of the procession to create a new Grand Federal
Procession on September 17, 1987 -- Constitution Day. This year's procession
will begin from the four points of the compass and conclude opposite the
Liberty Bell on Independence Mall. Satellite parades will take place
simultaneously in cities across the nation.
But like the 1788 parade, this year's parade
will also have American trade and industry as
one of its major focuses, Semingson says.
"You may very well see a float where people
are on mobile phones, or a float featuring the hotel and communications
industry," she says. "I'm sure the automobile industry and the labor
unions also will play an important part. The bottom line is that the Grand
Federal Procession should turn out to be truly magnificent, but also very
jolting and a real statement to where this country has come in the last 200
years."
The Grand Federal Procession will lead up to
four o'clock, when there will be a great rally led by the three branches of
government created by the constitution -- represented by the President, the Chief
Justice, and leaders of Congress, as well as a very solemn reenactment of the
signing of the constitution. The ceremony will include President Reagan, and
other celebrities who will represent
original signers such as John Adams, Benjamin
Franklin, and others.
WHO PAYS? Planning for all this activity is one
thing. But paying for it is another matter all together, as Semingson is quick
to point out. In fact, separate corporation was recently established to enable
celebration planners to legally raise the necessary funds and to sign required
contracts so that the We the People 200 plans could be carried out without a
hitch.
"We've done a lot of fundraising locally
already -- the foundations here have been terrific -- we've raised $7.38
million to date," Semingson says. "So the programs are in good shape.
We need to market the celebration, we need to publicize it, we need a very
strong public relations/promotion campaign. And we need money to do that."
She notes that currently there is a strong national
marketing effort underway to raise the need funds, part of which involves
approaching corporations for donations and sponsorships.
"I think it's important, but I don't think
corporations should be thinking in terms of making 'donations' or 'contributions'
-- I think they should be thinking about their marketing dollars,"
Semingson says. "They can approach this thing intelligently, just as the
corporations that were involved with the Statue of Liberty and the Olympics
did. In the end, the ones who were most satisfied with their participation were
those who figured out a way to self-liquidate their investment. In other words,
if you have a distribution system, you can have each of your distributors
participate so that the parent company isn't putting out the whole $2 million
itself."
FOUNDING SPONSORS: Currently the celebration
organizers are going after 13 "founding sponsors" in the two to three
million dollar range, and Semingson apparently feels very optimistic about the
group's chances of reaching that level.
"We think that those national sponsors that
we're dealing with currently that are most excited about joining us are the
ones who are really figuring out a way to market product or image by this
celebration," she says.
But the We the People 200 committee is by no
means working alone in its marketing efforts. According to Sam Rogers, Vice
President/Communications for the Philadelphia Convention and Visitors Bureau,
100 percent of the advertising budget has been allocated for this year's We the
People 200 celebration. His reasons are fairly clear.
"Certainly there is a great deal of
interest in the celebration itself on the national level, and from our
standpoint, a lot of potential business -- visitor business, on a national
level," he explains.
NATIONAL ADVERTISING: That budget, which is
worth approximately $1.7 million is broken down into several different
components. The biggest piece, $1 million, will be devoted to major magazines
such as Time, Travel & Leisure, Signature, Better Homes & Gardens,
Ladies Home Journal, and Ebony, Rogers says. In addition, there will be a
second magazine advertising campaign targeted toward the history-oriented
publications -- Americana, American Heritage, American History Illustrated, and
so on.
"We also have $400,000 in newspaper
advertising as part of an ongoing campaign which we flushed out 15 months ago,
targeted toward events on key weekends," Rogers says. "So now as we
move into the We the People era, the events we will be promoting, including
some of the traditional annual ones, will tie into that. And that campaign
basically involves papers from New York to Washington, including some of the
local papers -- the Inquirer Inquirer, Daily News -- depending on the event and
the interest, the demographics, etc."
Another $300,000 will be used for trade and
international trade advertising, with some substantial work being done in
England, Germany, Canada -- aimed basically at tour operators in those
countries. Other efforts are focused on a travel trade advertising, and efforts
to attract bus and tour operators, he says.
COMPANY IS COMING: In addition, there is a
program sponsored by the bureau entitled Company Is Coming, which will train
the first line ambassadors, those people who visitors see the first time -- the
concierge at a hotel, the taxi cab driver, an information booth attendant -- so
that visitors to the city will have an easier time getting around.
"That's terrific, and that's exactly the
kind of support we need in lots of areas," Semingson notes. "That's
the Convention & Visitors Bureau's job, and it's great that they're doing
their job -- but now we need to make sure that PhilaPride is doing their job
with the cleanliness of the city, and that city
services are above and beyond what they may
normally be."
"But hopefully this will set a model for
every year to come. If we can do it in '87, why can't we do it in '88 and
'89?" she says. "So I'm hoping that one of our lasting legacies,
besides a better educated populace, is that we leave models for how things can
get done in this community."
SUBSTANTIVE: That makes this year's celebration
just a little but more complicated than last year's Statue of Liberty
extravaganza. So comparisons to that event are probably unfair. The Statue of
Liberty, after all, was a visual symbol for millions of immigrants. The
constitution is also a symbol, but one that is much more esoteric.
"But then, again, we feel that the
constitution is more meaningful, more substantive," Semingson says.
"No doubt, the Statue of Liberty was a great rallying point. But the
Statue of Liberty was given to America by the people of France largely because
they were so impressed with our constitution. They admired what we had here and
they said 'Why can't we have what America has?' And they were referring to the
constitution. So we wouldn't have a Statue of Liberty if it wasn't for the
constitution."
Thus the challenge remains -- how to create a
program that is at the same time worthy of such a historic document,
meaningful, educational, fun and entertaining for the general public.
The program that is in place is impressive. And
if it can be carried out successfully, that challenge will no doubt be
fulfilled. But just in case, what about 200 Benjamin Franklin look-alikes?
Cities Battle for Conventions' Big Bucks
By Thomas Derr
09/10/1986
Focus
Pg. 58
Philadelphia, PA, US -- IN recent years, the
competition among cities to build major convention centers has exploded. New,
modern facilities worth hundreds of millions of dollars have appeared in San
Francisco, Dallas, Houston, New York, Washington, D.C., and Atlanta. Atlantic
City is building two -- a new municipal civic center, and a new $230 million
hotel/casino and bowling center that is being planned by the Showboat Hotel
& Casino and which will connect directly with two other casino/hotel
facilities. These are but a few.
Now Philadelphia has stepped into the foray.
With a new $430 million convention center due to be completed by 1991,
Philadelphia is aiming to seize its rightful share of the ever-increasing
meeting and conventions industry.
NEED MAJOR HOTEL: One of the major keys to
competing effectively will be the city's ability to attract a major hotel
developer, according to Thomas O. Muldoon, president of the Philadelphia
Convention and Visitors Bureau.
"When we look at our competing cities --
Boston, New York, Washington, Baltimore in particular, each of those major
cities has one or more of the five major convention hotel organizations in the
city," says Muldoon.
At the same time, one of Philadelphia's
limitations from a sales standpoint is that none of the five major convention
hotel organizations -- Hyatt, Hilton, Sheraton, Marriott and Weston -- have a convention
hotel presence in the city, he adds.
"And we are probably the only major city in
the country where that is the case," he says.
In fact, in some cities, the major hotel
magnates have a multiple presence. That fact provides host cities with an
important marketing advantage, as the sales and marketing staffs of these
facilities and their corporate parents' help supplement the convention bureaus
and other marketing arms of the host cities.
"The sales and marketing arms, and the
presence in the national marketplace -- particularly in New York, Washington,
and Chicago -- of the convention hotel companies is immense. Right now, in some
of the major markets, the only sales calls that originate from Philadelphia
come from our one or two people that are assigned to that marketplace,"
Muldoon says. "In competing cities, they may have one or two people from a
convention bureau, but they also have those two or three guys from the major
names in the convention business who are calling as well. And that makes a big
difference -- you can get some allies, and you also get some promotional
dollars."
COUNT THE LOSSES: In recent years, Philadelphia
has experienced a situation that is somewhat the reverse of that, notes Peter
R. Tyson, partner, Laventhol & Horwath, Philadelphia.
"You have a combination of the Convention
and Visitors Bureau, selling to get groups into the city, plus the combined
efforts of all the different hotel sales and marketing people. But every time
we lose a hotel in this city, the number of bodies that are out there beating
the bushes for new business decreases, and that's a negative."
The major problem is that over the last ten
years, a number of the city's older, convention-oriented properties have either
gone by the wayside, or have been converted to smaller, carriage-trade type
hotels. Therefore, the number of big convention sales staffs around the city
has decreased, Tyson explains.
"We've lost the Warwick. That used to be a
600-plus hotel that relied to a great degree on conventions, and the Ben
Franklin, which was a 1,200 room hotel," Tyson says. "We lost the
Bellevue Stratford twice, and whatever is done at the Bellevue -- if it's a 200
room hotel, they are not going to be looking for the convention business that
they looked for with a 500 room hotel, which is even less than they looked for
when it was a 700 room hotel."
Currently the only true convention-oriented
property in center city is the Franklin Plaza. There are also a number of
mid-sized hotels, such as the Hershey and the Holiday Inn at 18th and Market
streets that are close to convention-oriented size, but they primarily are
concerned with smaller group meetings, Tyson says.
One of the strongest benefits the new convention
center is likely to provide is that it will encourage the development of a
major (1,000-plus rooms) convention hotel, which will again give the city the
ability to readily accommodate large convention groups.
"Right now, if the city needed to house a
convention of 1,500 delegates, we would have to use four to six different
hotels, and from a meeting planner's standpoint, that's ridiculous. It creates
so many headaches. I'm sure that it puts us at a tremendous disadvantage to
other, much smaller cities, where they can accommodate those kinds of groups in
one, maybe two hotels at the most," says Tyson.
ATLANTA HAPPENING: According to Elizabeth Berry,
public relations director for the Georgia World Congress Center, in Atlanta,
the growth in major convention hotel space in that city has been dramatic since
the center was first opened in 1976.
Berry says four major hotels opened in Atlanta
during the center's first year, including the 1,200-room Peachtree Plaza, a
1,000-plus Hilton hotel, and a 1,600-room Marriott hotel. With the addition of
two more convention-sized hotels last year, Atlanta now has eight to ten
modern, convention hotel properties, Berry adds.
The annual income provided by the resulting
business is impressive. According to Berry, the amount of new dollars generated
by the Georgia World Congress Center in 1985 amounted to nearly $370 million.
Total taxes raised by city and state governments as a result of convention
activities amounted to more than $31 million.
LET'S LOOK AT THE FIGURES: The International
Association of Convention and Visitor Bureaus recently released a report which
detailed the average amount of money spent by convention attendees across the
county, as well as how that money was spent.
According to the report, on the average, each convention
accounted for approximately $660.57 per attendee during a convention stay in
1985. On the average, each convention lasted four days in duration.
That figure breaks down as follows. Each
attendee at the convention directly spent an average of $419.26 while in his or
her host city. At the same time, the convention host -- that is, the business
association or professional society, or other group which convened the meeting
-- spent an average of $44.90 per attendee during the convention, an average of
$183.84 per attendee on exhibits at the convention, and $12.57 per attendee on
exposition contractors such as electrical and mechanical services.
In addition, the association worked out the
percentages that relate to the amount of money spent directly by each
convention attendee. According to the report, 46.8 percent went to hotel rooms,
24.1 percent was spent on food, and another 11 percent went to retail stores in
the host city.
IS IT A PROFIT CENTER?: Opponents of convention
centers often point out that most major convention facilities in the country
operate in the red. According to a recent survey, San Francisco's famed Moscone
Center lost approximately $2.5 million, while the D.C. Convention Center showed
operating losses of nearly six million dollars. So the fact that few of the
country's major facilities ever show a positive bottom line might appear to be
a valid point of contention.
But as Thom Connors, an associate with Laventhol
& Horwath's Orlando-based Convention and Facility Group notes: "It is
a poorly stated point. Convention centers are built for a number of reasons.
First, they support an existing hotel industry, an existing entertainment
industry, and existing downtown business or commercial district; and second, to
create one."
Connors cites the case of Miami's downtown
convention center as an example. Although Miami's convention center is a
deficit operation, which creates something of a financial burden for the city,
it also serves as the anchor project within a downtown development district
which contains at least four hotel properties that did not exist five years
ago.
"These are major first-class, world-class,
convention quality hotels," says Connors. "And there are also a
number of office building structures and a lot of retail activity that didn't
exist before. There is a whole new look to the physical area that I'm sure has
encouraged other development."
Although the new convention center may not be
construed accurately as the soul reason for all the area's development, Connors
says that the city's confidence in that particular location more than likely
resulted directly in several of the new hotels being built.
"And that activity that was created spun
off other business activity," Connors adds. "People coming into the meetings
and conventions at that facility are spending money at those hotels and in
those downtown businesses -- buying food, spending money in retail shops, plus
the rent-a-cars, plus the taxis, plus the tips."
NEW INCOME: That money represents income that is
brand new to the city, points out Michael Boyle, vice president of the Meetings
and Conventions Division of Philadelphia's Convention and Visitors Bureau.
"What the convention delegates essentially
are doing is renting our city for a few days," says Boyle. "The money
those people bring in are dollars that are earned elsewhere and would not have
been spent in this city if it were not for the fact that a convention was held
in Philadelphia."
That new income often means new jobs for a city,
in addition to the obvious increase in sales revenues. As Laventhol &
Horwath's Connors notes, these new jobs can involve any number of possibilities
-- there are meeting room decorators, laborers who set up exhibits, additional
staff at the food service companies who serve the various convention groups,
security people, transport
workers, communications staff, additional hotel
staff, and so on.
"Those are all business opportunities and
sales that didn't exist before," says Connors. "Those are jobs that
didn't exist. That is why I think you have to look at that kind of spin-off and
economic impact within a community to really evaluate whether a convention
center is a deficit operation burdening the city government. In all the cases
I've seen it is certainly not. A convention center is a proven stimulus to
downtown development. Either redevelopment or ongoing urban development."
PRIVATE MANAGEMENT: That is not to say, of
course, that how a convention center is managed and operated is a moot point.
According to Matthew Brown, general manager of Philadelphia's Civic Center as a
member of Spectacor management services, there is a growing trend among city,
county and state governments to hire private management consultants to run
their convention facilities most effectively. For example, Spectacor manages
the following facilities in addition to the civic center: the Philadelphia
Spectrum, the Albany County Civic Center,
the Kellogg Center Arena in Battle Creek, MI, Three
Rivers Stadium in Pittsburgh, the Coliseum in Richmond, VA, and the Centrum in
Worcester, MA.
"The Spectrum is regarded as one of the
busiest and most successful buildings of its size in the country," notes
Brown. "What we have found is that there are communities out there who are
desperate for the same guidance and direction, and skill and expertise that has
been so successful at the Spectrum."
Brown notes that managing facilities designed
for entertainment is little different from managing stadiums, arenas and
convention centers. One fan of private management is L&H's Pete Tyson, who
has seen a "remarkable" rise in the level of expertise,
professionalism, and attitude in the Civic
Center's management.
"You now have people out there who feel they
have a fiduciary responsibility to book the place and to run events. Whereas
under the old regime, which was a public regime, there was no incentive. You're
a government employee and you go home at the end of the day and that's
that," says Tyson. "The Spectacor people seem to have the right
attitude. They want to get the business, and they
recognize some of the faults of the facility
itself and the service that has been offered, and they want to take steps to
correct it."
The key difference, says Conners, is that
private management companies typically have been able to attract the top
managers in the field. And by using highly trained professional managers who
implement programs that are proven effective, these private companies usually
can cut losses, decrease a facility's operating deficits, or even produce
significant amounts of new revenues to overcome a deficit operation. Of course,
private management is by no means a cure-all for every facilities ills.
LIMITATIONS: As Spectacor's Brown notes, Philadelphia's
existing Civic Center is simply insufficient for many of the large conventions
and trade shows that are now going to other cities.
"We can only advertise and sell the
capabilities of our facility, which although it has 400,000 square feet of space,
it is not all prime square footage. The Civic Center includes five different
buildings which fortunately, are connected, so it can provide continuous
space," says Brown.
But at the same time, two of the buildings date
back to the 1890s, and include limited square footage, narrow widths, and
columns that block out important exhibit space. This, together with the
relative lack of high quality hotel facilities in that area, hardly enhances
the facility's competitive edge in relation to newer facilities that are
springing up all over the country.
POSITIVE SIDE: But there is a positive side
here, too. The newest section of the Civic Center, Pennsylvania Hall, was
constructed fairly recently -- in 1978. Brown describes Pennsylvania Hall as
"an excellent facility" that is probably the "biggest secret in
the local business community." The facility features 11 meeting rooms,
ranging in capacity from 60 to 800 persons; 43,000 square feet of exhibit
space, and a 4,500-seat auditorium which can accommodate a banquet for 2,500
people -- putting it on a level with the Franklin Plaza as the largest facility
in the city, Brown says.
In addition, Pennsylvania Hall enjoys a separate
dining room and bar, a full kitchen, and a beautifully terraced entrance with
fountains and sculptures. According to Brown, Sun Co. and Bell of Pennsylvania
utilize the facility regularly for periodic stockholder and sales meetings.
Nevertheless, large-scale conventions, including
the Republican National Convention -- which Philadelphia has been rumored to be
courting for 1988, would probably be beyond the capacity of the complex, Brown
says.
LACK OF HOTELS: Once again, the major reason is
hotel rooms.
"You occasionally hear someone talking
about hosting a major convention or the Olympics, but when you find you have to
put people in Downingtown to have them properly housed, then I think you're in
for a bad time with the press. You're going to leave a bad taste in somebody's
mouth," observes Tyson. "The key is not to overshoot your abilities.
Keep it within the realm of reason, because all you need is to have the press
harp on the fact that it took an hour and a half to get into the site by bus,
and Philadelphia is going to come out with a black eye no matter how well the
thing is handled."
Tyson sees the Civic Center's future as being in
"gate shows," such as flower shows, boat shows, hobby shows, car
shows, and sportsmen shows. This use would complement the new civic center,
which would accommodate the major convention and group meeting exhibits, Tyson
notes.
"Certainly there will be some competition
between the two, but realistically speaking, the more facilities you can offer
within reason in a given geographic area, the stronger your competitive
position should be," Tyson says. "You could have two groups in town
at the same time, and if they have different needs, and if you have the hotel
room base to support them, it will be a terrific advantage to the city."
In addition, at about the same time the new
convention center opens, a new rail station will open at the Civic Center, thus
enabling easy access between the two facilities.
"It wouldn't be inconceivable for a group
to use Convention Hall for a general session for 11,000 people, and bring them
back to the new convention center via an underground shuttle," says the
Convention Bureau's Muldoon. "Or you can accommodate two different groups.
You are selling both facilities, and if you have three down days in setting up
the convention center and three to tear it down, you can make it financially
feasible for somebody to go into the civic center while you are tearing down
this place for the next show."
INGREDIENTS ARE THERE: And with the airport high
speed line, the lack of hotel rooms near the Civic Center is minimized.
"All you do is get on a train and then
you're down there. They pay a little less for their rooms, and a little less to
rent the older facility -- that way you are able to sell two packages, not just
one," explains Muldoon. "That's 'A' league, and that's got to be part
of our short-range planning."
"But facilities are what you start
with," Muldoon adds. "We have some tremendous strengths. Any
convention that comes to this city does excellent attendance. Approximately a
third of the nation's population is within a four or five hour trip of
Philadelphia, as well as probably 50 percent of the wealth that is in this
country. We're also sitting in the middle of the best marketing place in the
world, between New York and Washington.
"So from a convention standpoint, if we
have the right pieces and we sell them
right, we will be very, very successful."
The Mummers Gain 'Professional' Status With New Contract That Could
Bring in Millions
By Thomas Derr
05/07/1986
Focus
Pg. 17
Philadelphia, PA, US -- WHEN most people think
of the Philadelphia Mummers, they think of the color, the music, the pageantry,
and the contagious atmosphere of fun and excitement that seems to surround
their parades. One person, though, is taking the whole spectacle much more
seriously.
Art Wilkinson, president of Art Wilkinson and
Associates, a Philadelphia firm which normally specializes in business and
personal management service to professional athletes, broadcast media
personalities and coaches, recently negotiated a five-year contract with KYW-TV
on behalf of 49 of the 55 clubs who march in the Mummers New Years' Day Parade.
Wilkinson first came to national attention when
one of his clients, Heisman Trophy winner Mike Rozier, a Camden, N.J., native, made
news by making more money in a shorter period of time than any other player in
football history.
Wilkinson began his career as a labor and
contract lawyer for the federal government. While in Washington, he received a
Master's degree in labor law from George Washington University's National Law
Center, and shortly thereafter left the government to pursue a career as a
sports lawyer.
Today, as president of AWA, Wilkinson has
handled more than 50 well-known sports personalities, including: Tom Osborne,
head football coach at the University of Nebraska; Andy Talley, head football
coach at Villanova; Terry Kinard, former first-round draft choice of the New
York Giants; Joe Klecko, All-Pro defensive lineman for the New York Jets;
former Masters golf champion Craig Stadler; NHL power play record holder Tim
Kerr of the Philadelphia Flyers; and four-time Cy Young award winner Steve
Carlton. The firm also handles such media personalities as Merrill Reese,
sports director at WIP radio; and Judi Barton, arts and entertainment reporter
for KYW-TV.
MILLION DOLLAR PARADE: Now, thanks in large part
to Wilkinson's experience in dealing with some of those multi-million dollar
contracts, Philadelphia will soon be enjoying a million dollar parade.
Although Wilkinson will not discuss specific
details of the contract, he did say that the Mummers are much closer than ever
before to the kind of numbers commanded by other major national parades, such
as the Tournament of Roses Parade in Pasadena, CA, which is worth approximately
$6 million.
This is particularly significant in view of the
fact that only six years ago, Channel 6 paid a total of $15,000 for the rights
to the television broadcast of the Mummers Parade, and subsequent reruns,
Wilkinson notes.
"And when Channel 10 picked up the parade,
they never paid more than $220,000 for the entire parade. We thought that the
string bands themselves were worth that much money," he notes.
According to Wilkinson, the advertising revenues
and the ratings that are enjoyed by the stations which have broadcast the
Mummers more than justified his belief that the Mummers could command larger
rights fees. "I think it has been exploited in years past," he adds.
FORMER MUMMER: Wilkinson has personal experience
to draw from in making that observation, having been a Mummer himself for ten
years. At the age of 11, Wilkinson began playing the alto sax for the Duffy
String Band, and later played with both the Greater Kensington String Band and
the Greater Overbrook String Band.
"I knew the spirit of the Mummers, and you
can't put a price on that. So I just tried to get them to best deal I
could," says Wilkinson.
He adds that being a Mummer was a year-round job
involving countless rehearsals, practices, costume fittings and benefit appearances.
But it all comes together on New Year's Day, when the Mummers get up at two in
the morning to walk eight miles in freezing weather for a mere four minutes in
front of the judges' stand -- and then it's right back to the drawing board
again.
However, Wilkinson's business affiliations with
the Mummers came several years later, when Joe Deighan, president of the
Philadelphia String Band Association, asked him to provide professional help on
a recording contract. His involvement gradually became greater until taking on
the TV rights negotiations seemed to be a natural carryover, Wilkinson adds.
During the negotiations, several local TV
stations showed interest in broadcasting the 12-hour parade, he notes,
including Channels 29, 57, and, of course, 10, which had the TV rights since
1980. In the end, however, KYW, Philadelphia's NBC affiliate, came up with the
best offer, which included a promise that its Group W sister stations in San
Francisco, Boston, Pittsburgh and Baltimore would run at least part of the
parade.
One of Wilkinson's long-term objectives is to
persuade at least a few of these stations to pick up
the entire parade.
HOME-GROWN: KYW's victory in the wrestling match
for the Mummers Parade has been an objective of general manager Jim Thompson
since he assumed the position at the station in 1985. And, like Wilkinson, his
feelings are home-grown as well. Thompson claims to have missed only one parade
in the last 30 years -- and he only missed that one because he was serving a
tour of duty in Vietnam, he says.
"The Mummers Parade is pure Philadelphia,
with everyone working together for a common goal. Not only are we delighted to
be able to bring that spirit into Delaware Valley homes, but we are proud to be
able to show that neighborhood spirit to people across the country,"
Thompson says.
Those sentiments were echoed by Joe Deighan,
president of the Philadelphia String Band Association.
"In the past we were all underpaid and
often did our best just to make do. But now we can have finer costumes,
professional choreography and better make-up. This can't help but make for a
better parade," says Deighan. "And with the national exposure we hope
to get even more engagements during the year -- and that's important, too. It's
often hard for most Philadelphians to realize, but people only 100 miles away
usually don't know what the Mummers are all about."
EXPOSURE TO MARKETS: And along with the greater
national exposure will come greater national marketability, Wilkinson hopes.
"Right now we are forming a new company
called String Band Properties, which essentially will be a marketing arm for
the string bands," says Wilkinson. "It will market records, books,
video tapes, posters, T-shirts, and other items. That's something that has
never really been done before; in fact, I don't think it's ever been thought of
before."
Based on some preliminary studies on information
regarding prior record and program sales, attendance at the String Bank Show of
Shows, and other areas of interest, Wilkinson believes there is quite a
substantial amount of interest out there.
"And I think that the bands will probably
reap some pretty hefty benefits from somebody finally putting this package together
for them," he observes. In addition, the Mummers should also be able to
look forward to more national TV commercials, and engagements all over the
country at state fairs, conventions, malls and cultural exchange programs as a
result of the wider national exposure.
COMMERCIAL FLOATS: This exposure will provide
additional direct benefits for the Mummers because the new TV contract allows
them to retain the syndication rights to the parade in areas of the country not
covered by Group W (by broadcasting directly off the KYW feed). Furthermore,
each division can also have a commercial float leading it.
According to Wilson, national beer companies,
soft drink firms, airlines and fast food companies will probably be among the
many advertisers who will want to take advantage of such an opportunity.
"Throughout the years of the TV contract we
think the parade will become a national event," notes Wilkinson.
"Already, we've had calls from some out-of-town sources looking to bring
string bands in for specific events. And I think the more that we can have them
appear in different parts of the country, the more marketable the entire
concept will be."
Based on this exposure, Wilkinson says, major
endorsements and sponsorships -- as well as additional appearances -- will
become a real possibility for the Mummers.
"I really feel that this TV contract has
probably been the biggest single impact item on the history of the
parade," he claims. "The bands and the fancy brigades and the other
groups have been spending a substantial amount of dollars on their costumes
every year. But right now, with the new money that will come in with the TV
contract, and from some other sources that we have lined up, if some of the
Mummers want to, they may be in a position where they can spend two to three
times the money than before. And at that point, of course, we'll have ourselves
a better parade, which ultimately becomes a more marketable product."
BENEFITS TO CITY: But the ultimate benefits of
an enhanced Mummers Parade go far beyond the parade itself. In the long run,
claims Wilkinson, the entire city could be better off.
"We hope we can bring more people in for
the summer Mummers parade, and we certainly hope that we can appear in other
cities to make those people want to come here and see what else we have to
offer," says Wilkinson.